← ELI5 · Nestor G Pestelos Jr

System Safety · Picture Book

What Does Fail-Closed Mean?

When the safety light breaks, the gate stays shut.

1. The gate needs a green light

The gate opens only when the system can prove that the request is allowed.

ALLOWEDGate opens

2. No answer means stop

If the policy is missing or the check fails, the gate does not guess.

UNKNOWN?Gate stays shut

3. A safe stop can ask for help

The system can ask a clarifying question or hand the decision to the host.

UncertainrequestAsk guestAsk hostSafe

4. “Use the old copy” is a separate rule

A last-known-good fallback works only when an older safe copy was saved and the system was told to use it.

New policywill not loadValidated old policyUse only if fallbackwas designed and tested

Back to top

Longer version: Fail-Closed reference entry

Sources: RFC 4949; Saltzer and Schroeder, “The Protection of Information in Computer Systems” (1975).